Nutter Butter Cookies for Christmas (Easy!)

Join the festive fun with these traditional Nutter Butter cookies for Christmas. I have four easy ideas that all just take minutes to make. Decorating these no-bake Christmas cookies is a breeze! You’ll love this recipe for parties, school, or your holiday family gatherings. If you have missed any of the fun this week, be sure to check out the posts from day 1, day 2, and day 3.

Fall in love with all of my other popular Christmas crafts and ideas! You’ll find something for the whole family here. Decorating cookies has never been more fun!

Make Your Own Nutter Butter Cookies for Christmas

Want to spend the day baking fun, traditional, and enchanting Christmas cookies? These popular Nutter Butter cookies are delicious and satisfyingly sweet with shades of holiday colors and Santa Clause themes. If you’re looking for a way to celebrate during the holidays, then keep scrolling because there are a variety of cookie ideas here!

How to Make the Best Nutter Butter Snowman Cookies

Supplies Needed

• White Candy Coating
• Mini M&Ms
• Black Non-Pareils
• Orange Sprinkles
• Nutter Butter Cookies

Note: You can find most of these ingredients online or at your local grocery store!

Melt the candy coating according to the package directions. Coat the cookies with white candy coating. Lay on waxed or parchment paper. Add on M&M buttons, nonpareils smile and eyes, and sprinkle nose while the candy coating is still wet. Allow setting before serving or packaging.

How to Make the Best Santa Cookies

• White Candy Coating
• Mini Chocolate Chips
• White Sugar Pearls
• Mini M&Ms
• Red sugar
• Nutter Butter cookies

Melt the candy coating according to the package directions. Coat the cookies with white candy coating on both ends only. Dip top in red sugar leaving a small white band. Lay on waxed or parchment paper. Add on M&M nose, chocolate chip eyes, and white pearl ball for the hat using additional candy coating. Allow setting before serving or packaging.

How to Make Elf Nutter Butter Cookies Recipe

• White Candy Coating
• Mini Chocolate Chips
• White Sugar Pearls
• Mini M&Ms
• Green sugar
• Black writing Icing
• Nutter Butter cookies

Melt the candy coating according to the package directions. Coat the cookies with white candy coating on one end only. Dip in green sugar leaving a small white band. Lay on waxed or parchment paper. Add on M&M nose, chocolate chip eyes, and white pearl ball for the hat using additional candy coating. Draw on a mouth with black writing icing. Allow setting before serving or packaging.

How to Make Christmas Nutter Butter Reindeer Cookies

• Chocolate Candy Coating
• Mini M&Ms
• Candy Eyes
• Pretzels
• Nutter Butter Cookies

Melt the candy coating according to the package directions. Coat these cookies with chocolate candy coating. Lay on waxed or parchment paper. Add on pretzel antlers, candy eyes, and M&M nose while the candy coating is still wet. Allow setting before serving or packaging.

How to Use Christmas Cookies

These cookies for Christmas are the perfect no-bake treat for your event. Add a few of these to a large platter to serve your guests. I love how easy they are but your guests will love how cute they are!

Serve these cookies with milk or tea, main courses, Christmas parties–you name it! We like to leave these cookies out on Christmas Eve! Santa loves these cookies, and so do I!

Love this Idea and Want More? Click the Links Below!

• Fun Holiday Gift Tags
• Christmas Pillows
• Yarn Wrap a Mason Jar
• Christmas Tree
• Jingle Bell Ornament
• Popourri Holiday Gift