Have you ever wanted to do a test on sublimation vs. HTV? Which would last the longest? Does a printable HTV last as long as regular HTV? Well, I thought I would test a bunch of products all in one epic test to see which heat transfer product is the best. Find out below which you should be using on all of your fabric crafts!
Can’t watch the video or missed some of the information? You can also follow along below as I walk through my process.
Materials Tested:
- Cricut Iron-on
- Siser HTV
- BFlex HTV
- Starcraft printable HTV for dark fabrics
- Starcraft printable HTV for light fabrics
- WALAPaper Inkjet Light
- WALAPaper Inkjet Dark
- Infusible Ink Sheets
- Infusible Ink Markers
- Artesprix markers
Other Supplies Needed:
- Artesprix Sublimation Shirt (please note that this is polyester)
- Cricut EasyPress
- Inkjet Printer
- Sublimation Printer
- Sublimation Paper
- Protective paper
- Sublimation Ink
- Heat resistant tape
- Protective mat
Test Procedure:
Now let’s talk about how I am going to test all of these materials.
- I cut each material on my Cricut machine in a similar size and shape along with the name of the material so I would be able to tell them apart once placed on the shirt. In the case of the markers, I drew the design with my Cricut then filled in manually with markers.
- I then weeded all of my designs so I was left with a stack of materials ready to add to a shirt.
- I applied the designs to my shirt individually with an EasyPress so that I was able to adjust the temperature and time for each of the different materials. Please note that I am applying these materials to two shirts that are exactly the same. That way I can wash one and keep one unwashed for comparison purposes. Also, using an EasyPress was a choice I made to keep the application of so many materials easy and to make this test more accessible.
- I was left with two shirts that had a BUNCH of materials on them and they were ready for the wash. I started washing these shirts several times and noting any changes after each cycle. You can see all of my findings below. The wash cycles were all with the shirt inside out and with cold water. I hung the shirt to dry 30 of the times and threw it in the dryer 5 times to see if that had any effect.
Test Results
Here are the results of each of the products that I applied to my shirt:
Cricut Iron-on
This one surprised me by being the HTV product that lasted the longest. After 35 washes, it was just beginning to crack at the top of the heart and get maybe one small bubble in it. Otherwise, it looked great even though the shirt was obviously starting to wear.
Siser HTV
This HTV failed first. After the 35 washes, there was significant bubbling under the HTV and it was really starting to look bad. I would say this one starts to fail around 24 to 25 wash cycles.
BFlex HTV
The BFlex was somewhere in between the Cricut and the Siser. It did really crack at the top where the heart was cut, however. I would say it would be deemed a failure around 27 washes.
Starcraft printable HTV for light fabrics
I didn’t like this version of printable HTV when I tested it the first time, however, I had several people say they like it. Once again, the application was not good from the start. I do not recommend this version for shirts at all.
Starcraft printable HTV for dark fabrics
This is the printable HTV that I use on all fabrics (light or dark). It worked the best out of all of the printable products that I tested but it still had significant cracking around wash 13 or 14.
WALAPaper Inkjet Light
These heat transfer papers are really only good for around 3 washes. After that, they start to really degrade. I would only recommend them if you need a shirt to wear a few times.
WALAPaper Inkjet Dark
Once again, this is similar to the light version above. These do not last very long and are more for temporary applications when you need a quick shirt that you won’t need to wear many times.
Infusible Ink Sheets, Infusible Ink Markers, Artesprix markers, and Sublimation
All of the sublimation options performed equally well. After 35 washes, there wasn’t any difference that could be noted. So no fading, no cracking, and no wear. Seriously, this stuff is the ultimate way to make shirts!
I don’t feel like any of these methods were any better than any other. So, if you have a sublimation printer or a Cricut machine or can draw with markers, you should be able to make some shirts that will last a really long time.
Which heat transfer product should you use?
So, now that we have taken a look at sublimation vs. HTV, what should you use for your crafts? If you can use a shirt that is at least 75% polyester, I would go with sublimation, Infusible Ink, or Artesprix markers. If you need a cotton shirt, then I would go with Cricut HTV first or BFlex second. Need a printable product and only have an inkjet printer? Try Starcraft Printable HTV for dark fabrics no matter what color your fabric is.
I hope this comparison helps you decide which material will work best for your craft projects. It took me a while to make this sublimation vs. HTV comparison post but I think it was well worth it. Some of the results even surprised me!
So, even if you are an experienced crafter, you may be surprised at how these heat transfer materials perform over a long period of time. I have some more products lined up for some future tests as well so be sure to stay tuned. If you love this sublimation vs HTV comparison, you will love those future posts as well!
Love this post and want more ideas? Try the links below as well!
Very interesting and thorough. But this is only on polyester which is god awful to wear. Can you do a post on poly/cotton or just cotton. I know sublimation only works on poly. But what is the best vinyl for cotton or poly/ cotton?
I may do a full HTV comparison in the future so stay tuned!
I just love this testing of all those materials, this is very much helpful. I will make sure to print these infos and keep it close to me so next timeI decide on such a project and can use the best possible product. I also love watching your videos, your explanations are always clear and you don’t bla! bla! bla! about your cat and your dog (I am sure you know what I mean). Thanks again and continue this great work. 🥰
Thanks so much for the tips. It saved me alot of time and money!!